TwilightTeens

I know this sounds mean, but does anyone actually like Rosalie?


I think we the people were supposed to feel sorrow for her in the third book when she told her story of how she became a vampire... but maybe I have no heart.

I cannot see past her crazy behavior, and I just really do not like her... at all.



How do you guys feel about Rosalie?

yes *nods head in enthusiasm*
she had everything and it was torn away from her and everything she wants she cannot have, she maybe selfish but if she wasn't in the books the cullens would have no diversity and everyone would like bella she shows a different side to being a vampire and an opposing viewpoint of being a vampire

I like Rose.
Yes she is selfish, self centered etc. but that is how she was brough up...that's WHEN she was brought up...
She shows in Eclipse that she is not as bad as is percieved...
She has a history too to how she is and I feel we should respect that...
<3x

i like rose now after i read eclipse. i thought she was a bit mean in the first one and it was wrong to tell edward bella had died, even if she hadn't, but after eclipse, i could see why she was like that.

I like her despite her attitude. She's coming around to Bella, and she does feel sorry for her miscommunication that caused Edward to nearly commit suicide...I believe that was genuine. And I love that she and Emmett are so devoted to each other. She's his angel, and she loves him as much as he loves her. I think she's going to have a bit of a bigger part in Breaking Dawn, and I think we're going to see a change in her.

I don't really feel pitty for her though. If you think about it, Esme didn't want to be a vampire either. She commited suicide and was forced into vampireism. Carlisle also was forced, but they are two of the kindest people in the book... they turned their lives around.

I know Rosalie was brought up like her charachter, but I think she should build herself a bridge and get over complaining about what she missed out on. Her present life won't get any better if she is negative about the past all the time...

But I do see how she adds diversity to the book.
She is important, I won't disagree with that, but she still annoys me hah

Hahaha...I liked that...
I'm sure she can build a bridge very fast too lol...

i actually like her.
her story/history is extremely interesting to me.
like how she would dress up in her wedding dress and go on the killing spree.
its extremely different than all the other vampire's stories.

classyaffair_ wrote:like how she would dress up in her wedding dress and go on the killing spree.

i always thought that would be so fun to scare all of those men. i bet they were scared to go out at night when they heard about the first deaths and knew they'd be next.

I'm actually so glad she did that...
That was the very LEAST those b*******s deserved
I would have made their death as slow and painful and as terrifying as possible...
Especially Roynce's...

in my opinion, rosalie is the most misunderstood character in the series. a lot hate her because she is seen as vain, self-centered and selfish. but this is probably because of the way she had been brought up and from all the attention she had and has been getting from everyone (it's not hard to imagine someone who's been receiving a lot of attention let all the fame/feeling get into his/her head). but just because she is portrayed in the book as someone who cares about her beauty and own welfare doesn't make her as that kind of stereotype, period. actually, she is someone simple who, though smitten by vanity, wants what almost every woman in her time wants - which is to be married and have - most especially - have kids of her own, and this was all taken away from her eternally.

ForeverEponine wrote:in my opinion, rosalie is the most misunderstood character in the series. a lot hate her because she is seen as vain, self-centered and selfish. but this is probably because of the way she had been brought up and from all the attention she had and has been getting from everyone (it's not hard to imagine someone who's been receiving a lot of attention let all the fame/feeling get into his/her head). but just because she is portrayed in the book as someone who cares about her beauty and own welfare doesn't make her as that kind of stereotype, period. actually, she is someone simple who, though smitten by vanity, wants what almost every woman in her time wants - which is to be married and have - most especially - have kids of her own, and this was all taken away from her eternally.

Well said, I completely agree...

TwilightAngel wrote:

ForeverEponine wrote:in my opinion, rosalie is the most misunderstood character in the series. a lot hate her because she is seen as vain, self-centered and selfish. but this is probably because of the way she had been brought up and from all the attention she had and has been getting from everyone (it's not hard to imagine someone who's been receiving a lot of attention let all the fame/feeling get into his/her head). but just because she is portrayed in the book as someone who cares about her beauty and own welfare doesn't make her as that kind of stereotype, period. actually, she is someone simple who, though smitten by vanity, wants what almost every woman in her time wants - which is to be married and have - most especially - have kids of her own, and this was all taken away from her eternally.

Well said, I completely agree...

I think the reason she doesn't appeal to me is I really don't like that lifestyle... where you have kids and get married and settle down.... I think thats why I LOVE edward and bella's relationship. They are engaged in all that, but there is so much tension that it is just AMAZING and totally out of the ordinary... They have something very rare

When first reading the books I didn't like her very much.
But reading what happend to her in Eclipse made me feel really badly for her. To have that horrific thing happen to her...and I do get why she's a little "off" with Bella.

But what annoys me is how vain she is.
Thats why I'm not too fond of her

I am not really sure if I like her or not